THE FLIPSIDE
The Flipside is a space for rethinking music education. Through honest reflection, bold ideas, and real-world experiences, this blog challenges traditional assumptions and explores what music learning can become. From modern band and inclusive practices to creativity, community, and lifelong musicianship, The Flipside looks beyond “the way it’s always been” and asks what truly serves students.
MUSIBUS: The Bus That Could Go Anywhere, But Didn't
MUSIBUS was inspired by three experiences. In graduate school, my professor Judy Bowers introduced me to William Raspberry's 1997 allegory Publibus, published in The Washington Post as "Bus Bust," which used public transportation as a metaphor for public education. Years later, a conversation with my wife, Shelley, led me to think about how school music programs might already have the capacity to serve more students if we reconsidered how they operate. Most recently, at the 2026 Iowa Music Educators Association Conference, Minnesota educator David Davis shared his Framework for Systemic Transformation, moving from "The Way It's Always Been Done" through "Student Voice & Choice," "Courage to be Skeptical," and "Our Own Creativity," toward "Community-Building." His framework reminded me that meaningful change begins when we're willing to question familiar practices, listen to students, and imagine new possibilities. Together, these experiences inspired MUSIBUS.
Where Are the Curbs in Music Education?
What if Universal Design for Learning (UDL) wasn't just about adapting existing music classes, but rethinking which classes we offer? Modern band, songwriting, and music production can remove barriers for students with disabilities while opening exciting musical opportunities for many others. Using the familiar curb-cut analogy, this post explores how expanding school music programs can make music education more accessible, inclusive, and meaningful for everyone.
The Musician We Might Have Missed
Doug Yee’s journey from childhood music lessons that didn’t connect to performing with Kroqodiles raises a question: Who are we missing in school music? Through friendship, baseball, and a memorable night at House of Blues, his story reminds us to recognize every student’s potential, nurture their contributions, and offer opportunities to build a musical life they want to keep pursuing.
What Sports Understands That Music Education Can Learn From
Sports creates experiences people want to attend, traditions families share, and communities people feel part of. Rather than resenting the attention sports receives, music educators might study what it gets right. This post explores what sports can teach us about audience, belonging, participation, and creating experiences people genuinely want to join.
The Unequal Disclaimer: Why Does Modern Band Advocacy Sound Like an Attack?
Modern band educators are sometimes treated as anti-band simply for advocating passionately for what they teach. Yet band, choir, and orchestra directors routinely celebrate their ensembles without apology. Why the unequal standard? Perhaps equity in music education also means giving every educator permission to love, advocate for, and critically examine their approach without having to defend it against the traditions already at the center.
Before the Students Took the Stage, Their Coaches Did
At Amp Camp, students learned performance by watching their own teachers and coaches take the stage. Staff bands modeled how musicians embody music, connect with one another, and share energy with a crowd. Meanwhile, campers practiced being enthusiastic audience members. Together, these experiences transformed the final concert into a joyful community celebration rather than a formal recital under quiet observation.
Learning From Practice: Moving From Experience to Professional Judgment
Teaching experience does not automatically produce professional learning. Experience becomes educational when we examine it carefully, separate observation from interpretation, question our initial explanations, and use what we learn to make better decisions. Learning from practice is not about proving that a teaching approach worked. It is about developing the professional judgment to decide what to retain, revise, or try next.
What Would Count as Evidence? Looking for Learner Responsibility
Learner-centered teaching is not proven by participation, enjoyment, compliance, or a successful performance. Evidence of learner responsibility appears when students identify problems, explain decisions, choose strategies, revise their work, evaluate results, and determine what to do next. When trying a shift, the goal is not to prove it works, but to observe carefully and learn from what happens in practice.
Choice Is Not Agency: Sharing Meaningful Responsibility With Learners
Choice can make a music classroom more engaging, responsive, and accessible, but it does not necessarily give learners responsibility for learning. This essay distinguishes activity, participation, choice, agency, and responsibility, then considers how teachers can transfer one meaningful area of musical or intellectual work while still providing the structure and support learners need to succeed and become increasingly independent musicians.
Who is Doing the Work
Who is doing the real work in your music classroom? Students may be playing, singing, moving, and participating while the teacher still makes every meaningful decision. This essay looks beneath visible activity to examine where thinking, listening, problem-solving, and musical responsibility actually occur, and how teachers can provide structure while helping learners develop greater independence, ownership, and agency over time.
The Teacher as the Band's Biggest Fan
We spend countless hours rehearsing notes, rhythms, and dynamics, but do we ever rehearse connecting with an audience? After leading a band at the Modern Band Summit, I began wondering if students perform the way they practice, not just musically, but socially. What if teachers became their students' biggest fans before the concert ever begins?
The Sharing Phase: Designing for Contribution
Designing Musical Growth – Essay 4
What is music ultimately for? Technical fluency and embodied participation are essential, but they are not the final destination. In this concluding essay of the Designing Musical Growth series, I explore how music becomes an act of generosity, something we offer rather than demonstrate, and why helping students contribute through music may be one of the highest purposes of music education.
The Embodiment Phase: Designing for Participation
Designing Musical Growth – Essay 3
What happens after students learn the notes? Too often, we assume expression will naturally follow. In this essay, I introduce the Embodiment Phase—the point where students move beyond simply producing music and begin participating through their whole body. Discover why movement isn't
The Technical Phase: Designing for Fluency
Designing Musical Growth – Essay 2
Technical fluency is essential, but it isn't the destination of music learning. In this essay, I explore how Cognitive Load Theory helps explain why students often look like "statues" when learning new music and why that's a normal part of the process. More importantly, I argue that the Technical phase should be intentionally designed to prepare students for ownership, expression, and meaningful musical connection.
What Kind of Musician Are We Trying to Develop?
Designing Musical Growth – Essay 1
That simple question has reshaped how I think about music education. In this essay, I introduce a new framework for understanding musical growth—not just as technical development, but as a journey from Technical, to Embodiment, to Sharing. What if the ultimate goal of music education is helping students use music to make a difference in someone else's life?
What Kind of Musician Does a Music Teacher Need to Be?
For decades, music teacher preparation has often borrowed its definition of musicianship from performers. But teaching music may require a different kind of expertise. This article explores why adaptability, breadth, and lifelong learning may be just as important as specialization in preparing the next generation of music educators.
Preparing Students for Musical Life
What is school music actually preparing students for once school ends? In this reflective essay, Kevin Droe explores the difference between performing music and truly participating in music, questioning whether traditional ensemble models fully prepare students for lifelong musical engagement. The piece examines self-directed musicianship, creativity, and the need to reconnect music education with real human musical life beyond school walls.
I Thought Music Teachers Had to Stand at the Center of the Room
I used to think becoming a music teacher meant becoming the person at the center of the room: confident, commanding, comfortable with everyone watching. The problem was, that never fully felt like me. For years, I thought something was wrong with that. This post is about discovering that teaching does not have to look only one way and neither does leadership.
My Students Aren’t Wrong: Part 3 - They Sit Still Because We Trained Them To
In Part 3 of “My Students Aren’t Wrong,” I reflect on watching modern band students sit motionless in rehearsal, not because they lacked passion, but because they were performing exactly how music education trained them to perform. This post explores the difference between technical accuracy and human connection, and asks what might happen if music education focused more on communication, energy, and audience engagement.
My Students Aren’t Wrong: Part 2 - They Want to Be the Conductor
In Part 2 of the “My Students Aren’t Wrong” series, I explore a question that has puzzled me for years: Why do some music education students seem more interested in conducting ensembles than working with children? I argue that students are responding logically to the systems they experienced. When musical value appears to come primarily from the conductor, it makes sense that students would aspire to become that person. But what happens when classrooms distribute value through creativity, participation, and shared music-making instead?