MUSIBUS: The Bus That Could Go Anywhere, But Didn't

Inspired by William Raspberry's 1997 allegory "Publibus," published in The Washington Post as "Bus Bust," an observation by my wife, Shelley, and David Davis's Framework for Systemic Transformation.

Every town had a bus called MUSIBUS. It was a beautiful bus. The engine ran smoothly, the seats were comfortable, and the people who maintained it took tremendous pride in keeping it in excellent condition. The drivers were highly trained, dedicated professionals who had spent years learning how to operate it. They cared deeply about their passengers and wanted every journey to be a wonderful experience.

And MUSIBUS went to some remarkable places. Every year, it traveled to beautiful destinations. Sometimes it visited neighboring towns. Other times, it ventured across the state or even across the country. Wherever it went, its passengers returned with wonderful stories about the places they had visited and the friendships they had made along the way. Many passengers developed skills they never imagined they would have, and some even went on to become drivers themselves.

The community loved MUSIBUS. People gathered to celebrate its departures and welcomed it home after particularly successful trips. Former passengers spoke fondly of their experiences, and many hoped their own children would someday ride the same bus. In some communities, MUSIBUS had been operating for generations, and the routes had become part of the town's identity. A large sign on the side of the bus even proudly read, "MUSIBUS: A Bus for Everyone!"

But there was something unusual about MUSIBUS. Most of the children in town had never ridden it.

That wasn't necessarily because the bus was full. In fact, on many trips, plenty of seats were empty. Riding MUSIBUS simply wasn't as easy as the sign suggested. For starters, passengers were expected to have certain skills before boarding. Some needed to begin preparing years in advance. Children who hadn't learned these skills early enough often discovered that getting on MUSIBUS later was surprisingly difficult. While some students were eager to learn these skills, others simply wanted to travel without spending years preparing for the journey.

Cost was also a factor. Although the community supported MUSIBUS, riding it wasn't always free. Some passengers needed to purchase expensive equipment. Others paid for additional instruction, special clothing, or particular trips. Families that could afford these expenses generally found them worthwhile. But some children couldn't afford the ticket, even when an empty seat was waiting for them.

And then there was the schedule. MUSIBUS often departed early, returned late, and occasionally required passengers to travel on weekends or during the summer. For some students, this was part of the adventure. For others, family responsibilities, jobs, or transportation difficulties made participation impossible. Some children wanted to ride but couldn't commit to every trip, and the bus didn't always offer the option to join only part of the journey.

Some children also spoke different languages or came from families with different traditions. Although many loved traveling, the instructions aboard MUSIBUS were unfamiliar, and the destinations rarely reflected places their families knew or valued. Some of these children knew wonderful places that MUSIBUS had never visited, but nobody had thought to ask them where they might like to go.

Perhaps the most interesting thing about MUSIBUS, however, was where it traveled. You see, MUSIBUS had been following essentially the same routes for generations. These were excellent routes. The drivers knew them well, the passengers enjoyed them, and the community celebrated the journeys. There was nothing wrong with the destinations themselves, but they weren't the only places worth visiting.

Some children wanted to visit different destinations. Others wanted to explore places closer to home. A few dreamed of creating entirely new routes rather than following maps drawn years earlier. Some wanted to travel with smaller groups of friends, while others wanted to visit places important to their families and communities. But MUSIBUS rarely traveled to those places, and so many children simply never boarded.

Eventually, people began to worry about the number of empty seats. At a community meeting, someone announced that MUSIBUS needed more passengers. Everyone agreed. The drivers worked harder to encourage children to ride. They visited younger students, organized special events, distributed colorful brochures, and invited families to learn about the wonderful places MUSIBUS traveled. Some new passengers came aboard, but most children who weren't riding still stayed away.

"Maybe children just aren't interested in traveling anymore," someone suggested. Another person nodded and remembered how, when they were young, everyone seemed to want to ride MUSIBUS. Some wondered whether children had simply changed or whether too many other activities were competing for their attention. After all, MUSIBUS was still providing wonderful journeys. Why wouldn't more children want to participate?

One afternoon, a woman who had been listening to these conversations asked a question. "Has anyone asked the children why they aren't riding?"

The room grew quiet. One of the drivers explained that some children simply weren't interested in the destinations MUSIBUS offered. The woman thought about this for a moment and asked, "Then why don't we go somewhere they want to go?"

The driver looked surprised. Those were the routes MUSIBUS had always traveled, and they were wonderful routes. Besides, the driver explained, there wasn't enough money to purchase another bus.

"I'm not suggesting another bus," the woman replied. "I'm wondering why this bus couldn't travel somewhere different."

The driver paused. The current passengers loved the places they visited, and the community had come to expect those journeys. Changing the routes might disappoint people who had supported MUSIBUS for years. But the woman wasn't suggesting abandoning the existing destinations. She wondered whether MUSIBUS could travel somewhere different on another day, whether some schedules could change, and whether passengers might help decide where they wanted to go.

Another driver pointed out that things weren't so simple. Resources were limited, and some towns had only one driver already responsible for maintaining the bus, planning trips, and getting everyone safely to their destinations. There simply weren't enough hours in the day to go everywhere.

The woman understood. She wasn't suggesting that the drivers weren't working hard enough or that new routes would be easy to create. Instead, she wondered whether the community had fully considered what its existing bus could do. Before purchasing another bus, hiring another driver, or asking the current drivers to work even longer hours, perhaps it was worth examining how MUSIBUS was already being used.

She pointed toward the bus parked outside. It could travel thousands of miles, take different roads, visit unfamiliar destinations, and carry all kinds of passengers. Yet year after year, it traveled to essentially the same places with many of the same kinds of passengers. The bus wasn't necessarily the limitation. Perhaps the routes were.

Someone in the back of the room worried that the community might lose something important if MUSIBUS began traveling to new destinations. The familiar journeys represented years of tradition, wonderful memories, and meaningful experiences. Nobody wanted those to disappear.

The woman agreed. The question wasn't whether the traditional trips were valuable. The question was whether they were the only trips worth taking.

For years, the drivers had asked how they could convince more children to ride MUSIBUS. But they had rarely asked the children what would make them want to ride. Once they began listening, they discovered something surprising. Many children weren't rejecting the idea of traveling. They simply had different ideas about where they wanted to go, how they wanted to get there, and what they hoped to experience along the way.

Some wanted shorter trips that didn't require years of preparation. Others wanted to explore entirely different destinations. Some wanted to travel with friends, while others wanted to visit places connected to their families and cultures. A few wanted to learn how to navigate, plan their own journeys, and discover destinations that weren't on any existing map.

For some drivers, these conversations were uncomfortable. They had dedicated their careers to mastering the familiar routes, and they were exceptionally good at what they did. Questioning those routes almost felt like questioning their own accomplishments. They knew how much work had gone into building MUSIBUS into something the community celebrated, and they worried about losing what made it special.

But gradually, they began recognizing an important distinction. They could be proud of everything they had accomplished while still wondering whether something different might serve more children. Being an excellent driver didn't necessarily mean traveling the same routes forever. Perhaps it also required the courage to ask whether those routes were taking passengers everywhere they wanted and needed to go.

The drivers began experimenting. They continued traveling to many of their traditional destinations, and those journeys remained wonderful experiences for the passengers who loved them. But MUSIBUS also began exploring new routes. Some trips were shorter, some were less expensive, and some required little previous experience. On certain trips, passengers helped choose the destinations. On others, they helped create the maps themselves.

As the drivers became more comfortable exploring unfamiliar destinations, they began contributing ideas of their own. They imagined route combinations nobody had considered, discovered new ways to use the bus, and found creative solutions to problems that once seemed impossible. The passengers brought their interests and experiences, while the drivers brought their knowledge and expertise. Together, they began creating journeys that neither group would have imagined independently.

Not every experiment worked. Some routes attracted few passengers, while others required schedule adjustments or additional resources. Drivers needed to learn unfamiliar roads, and the community had to reconsider longstanding expectations. In smaller towns, where there was only one driver, changes required especially careful planning. Sometimes offering a new destination meant reducing the number of trips to another. But people began recognizing that limited resources didn't necessarily mean they had to keep doing everything exactly as they always had.

Gradually, something remarkable happened. Children who had never considered riding MUSIBUS began showing up. They weren't necessarily less capable than the original passengers, and they hadn't suddenly developed an interest in traveling. Many had wanted to travel all along. They simply hadn't been interested in, or able to participate in, the particular journeys MUSIBUS had offered.

The original passengers continued enjoying many of their favorite trips. Some even tried the new destinations and discovered places they never would have visited otherwise. Friendships developed among passengers who previously had little reason to spend time together, and the bus began to feel like a place where more people belonged.

But perhaps the biggest surprise was what happened to the drivers.

At first, learning new routes had seemed like an additional responsibility. After years of mastering familiar roads, some drivers were understandably hesitant to venture into unknown territory. They were proud of their expertise and comfortable knowing exactly how to get their passengers to the destinations they had always visited.

But once they began exploring, they discovered something unexpected. There were extraordinary places they had never seen before. Some destinations were just as beautiful and rewarding as the familiar ones, even though they were entirely different. Others offered experiences the drivers hadn't known were possible. They began learning new ways to navigate, discovered unfamiliar landscapes, and developed skills they never imagined needing.

And they liked it.

The drivers also began learning things about their passengers that they had never known before. When passengers were invited to suggest destinations, the drivers heard stories about their families, neighborhoods, cultures, and interests. They discovered that some children knew routes the drivers had never traveled and could introduce them to places they might never have found on their own. Children who had once seemed quiet or disengaged suddenly became enthusiastic guides, sharing ideas and helping others discover new experiences.

The relationship between drivers and passengers began to change. Instead of always being the person who knew the route and told everyone where to go, the driver sometimes became a fellow traveler, learning alongside the passengers. The drivers were still responsible for keeping everyone safe and helping them develop the skills needed for the journey, but they no longer felt they had to know every destination before leaving the station.

Some drivers even discovered that these new journeys brought back feelings they hadn't experienced in years. The excitement of discovering an unfamiliar place, the satisfaction of learning something new, and the joy of seeing passengers become genuinely invested in their travels reminded them why they had wanted to become drivers in the first place.

Sometimes after returning from a new destination, the drivers found themselves telling friends and family about the wonderful places their passengers had introduced them to.

Perhaps the most unexpected change was what happened to the community itself. Children who had rarely interacted began traveling together. Passengers introduced one another to places, traditions, and experiences they might never have encountered otherwise. Families who had never paid much attention to MUSIBUS began showing interest in its journeys. The drivers developed relationships with students they might never have known, and the community began celebrating destinations that hadn't even been considered a few years earlier.

MUSIBUS was no longer simply a bus that transported a select group of passengers to impressive places. It was becoming something that connected people throughout the community.

Over time, the community began thinking differently about what made MUSIBUS successful. For years, success had been measured by how smoothly the bus operated, how impressive its destinations were, and how well its passengers completed their journeys. Those things still mattered, and nobody wanted to diminish the wonderful accomplishments of the passengers and drivers.

But now the community was asking another question. How many children actually had the opportunity to ride?

It was a question that hadn't received much attention when MUSIBUS was already considered so successful. The bus was beautiful, the drivers were talented, and the journeys were impressive. But somewhere along the way, the community had confused providing excellent experiences for some children with providing meaningful opportunities for all children.

MUSIBUS hadn't been broken. The drivers hadn't been doing a poor job, and the passengers hadn't been traveling to the wrong places. The familiar routes still had tremendous value, and there was every reason to continue celebrating them.

But MUSIBUS could do so much more than anyone had imagined. It could reach new destinations, welcome passengers who had never been aboard, and create experiences that enriched the lives of both travelers and the people driving the bus.

And perhaps the most important discovery was that expanding the journeys didn't simply make MUSIBUS better for the children who had been left behind. It also made the experience richer for the drivers and passengers who had been riding all along.

After all, what good is a beautiful bus that can travel almost anywhere if most of the children never get to ride?

And who knows what wonderful places we might discover if we simply invited more children to help us decide where to go?

A Reflection on MUSIBUS

MUSIBUS is a fictional story, but I wonder how closely it reflects the music education programs in our schools. We have incredibly talented teachers providing wonderful musical experiences for their students. Yet many children never participate in school music. We often respond by trying to convince more students to join the programs we've already designed. But what if we spent just as much energy asking students what kinds of musical experiences they actually want?

At the 2026 Iowa Music Educators Association Conference, David Davis shared his Framework for Systemic Transformation. His framework begins with "The Way It's Always Been Done," then moves through "Student Voice & Choice," "Courage to be Skeptical," and "Our Own Creativity," ultimately arriving at "Community-Building." What struck me most was the courage to be skeptical. It takes courage to question practices that have brought us success, especially when those practices are deeply connected to our professional identities.

But skepticism doesn't mean rejecting what we've accomplished. It means remaining curious about what else might be possible. And perhaps the most exciting part of that journey is that teachers themselves have something to gain. When we invite students to introduce us to their musical worlds, we may discover new music, new approaches to teaching, and new connections with the children in our classrooms.

Maybe the question isn't simply how we can get more students interested in the music programs we've already created. Maybe it's how we can create music programs that are more interested in the students we serve.

And perhaps the greatest opportunities in music education aren't necessarily waiting for us to purchase another bus. They may be waiting for us to imagine where the one we already have could go.

Acknowledgments and Inspiration

MUSIBUS draws inspiration from several people whose ideas have shaped my thinking about education.

In graduate school, my professor Judy Bowers introduced me to William Raspberry's allegory Publibus, which appeared in The Washington Post on October 13, 1997, under the title "Bus Bust." Raspberry used a public transportation system to examine the responsibilities and challenges of public education. His storytelling approach stayed with me for years and inspired the structure of MUSIBUS.

A recent conversation with my wife, Shelley, brought the bus metaphor back to mind. She observed that school music programs sometimes claim they don't “have room for more students,” even though relatively few students are riding the bus. Her observation led me to consider whether our existing music education resources could serve more students if we reconsidered how we use them.

Finally, David Davis's presentation at the 2026 Iowa Music Educators Association Conference helped connect these ideas to a process of educational change. His Framework for Systemic Transformation reminded me that meaningful change begins by listening to students, finding the courage to question established practices, using our creativity to imagine alternatives, and ultimately building stronger communities.

These three inspirations came together in MUSIBUS, a story about a bus that was already wonderful but could take many more children to places nobody had imagined.

Next
Next

Where Are the Curbs in Music Education?