Where Are the Curbs in Music Education?

What Modern Band Can Teach Us About Universal Design for Learning

One of my favorite examples of universal design is the curb cut. You probably encounter dozens of them every day without thinking much about them. They're places where a sidewalk gradually slopes down to meet the street, letting someone using a wheelchair move from one to the other without hitting a barrier.

But think about who else benefits from that curb cut. Parents pushing strollers, people pulling suitcases, cyclists, delivery workers, and even someone simply walking who would rather not step off a curb. What was designed to make sidewalks accessible to people with disabilities ended up making sidewalks more accessible and convenient for everyone.

That's one of the beautiful things about universal design. When we design something to remove barriers for people with disabilities, we often discover that the changes benefit a much larger group of people.

I've been thinking about how this concept applies to music education, particularly modern band, songwriting, digital music production, and other forms of popular music education. And the more I think about it, the more I believe these approaches offer a wonderful example of what universal design can look like in our schools.

But perhaps not in the way we typically think about it.

Universal Design Beyond the Classroom

Most music educators are familiar with Universal Design for Learning, or UDL. The framework encourages us to design learning environments that recognize the variability of students and provide multiple ways for them to engage with content, understand information, and demonstrate their learning.

In a music classroom, that might mean providing visual supports, modifying an instrumental part, letting students learn by ear rather than through notation, or giving them different ways to demonstrate their musical understanding. These practices matter, and music teachers should keep exploring them.

However, I wonder if we've been thinking about universal design on too small a scale.

Most discussions of UDL in music education seem to focus on what happens inside an existing classroom. We take the music class we already offer and consider how to make that experience more accessible to a wider range of students.

But what if we applied universal design to the larger structure of our music programs? What if, instead of asking only how we can make band, choir, or orchestra more accessible, we also asked whether our music classes offer enough opportunities for students with different interests, abilities, and musical backgrounds? That question opens up some interesting possibilities.

What If the Curb Is the Course Itself?

Imagine a student with a disability who loves music but finds participating in a traditional large ensemble challenging. Perhaps reading notation is difficult, keeping up with rehearsal pace creates barriers, or the physical or social environment makes participation difficult. As music educators, we might begin thinking about accommodations. Could we modify the music? Could we adapt an instrument? Could we change how we deliver instruction? Those are all worthwhile questions.

But what if that student had another option?

What if the school offered a digital music production course where students could create beats, experiment with loops, record sounds, and compose their own music? Or a modern band class where students could play guitar, bass, drums, keyboards, sing, or contribute through music technology? Or a songwriting course where students could express themselves musically without necessarily needing to perform in a traditional ensemble? These courses would still need thoughtful design to be accessible. But they could remove some barriers in more traditional approaches to school music.

Now here's where I think the curb-cut analogy becomes especially interesting.

Imagine how many other students at that school might want to take those classes. Students who love hip-hop. Students who dream of producing their own songs. Students who play guitar in their bedrooms but have never considered joining a school ensemble. Students interested in electronic music, video game music, or writing songs with their friends. Students who simply don't see their musical interests reflected in the current offerings.

Suddenly, a course developed partly to make music education more accessible to students with disabilities becomes an opportunity for students across the school. Just like the curb cut. The course isn't a separate accommodation for a particular group of students. It's a new pathway into music education that potentially benefits everyone. And to me, that's one of the most exciting possibilities of applying universal design to music education.

What About the Students Who Never Enroll?

When we discuss accessibility in music education, we often focus on the students who are already in our classrooms. We think about the students in our band rehearsals, choir classes, orchestra programs, and general music classrooms. We ask how we can better meet their needs. But what about the students who aren't there? I think this is an important question that doesn't receive nearly enough attention.

Consider a high school where students can choose between band, choir, and orchestra. The teachers may be wonderful. The ensembles may perform beautifully. The students who participate may have extraordinary experiences. Again, what about the students who don't enroll? We might assume they simply aren't interested in music. Yet I suspect many of those students are deeply interested in music. They listen to it constantly. They share songs with friends, attend concerts, create playlists, experiment with instruments, and sometimes make music on their own.

They just aren't interested in the particular musical experiences their school offers.

Some students may also face barriers that make those courses hard to access, including prerequisites, scheduling conflicts, financial constraints, or the nature of the learning environment. So perhaps the question isn't whether those students are interested in music. Perhaps the question is whether we've designed music programs that offer them something meaningful. This is where I think universal design can challenge our assumptions.

We can make an existing classroom more accessible, but if students don't see that classroom as a place where they belong, they may never walk through the door.

We can't accommodate students who never enroll.

If we genuinely want music education to be accessible to everyone, shouldn't we also consider the students missing from our programs?

Accessibility Doesn't Have to Mean Accommodation

There's an important distinction between providing an accommodation and designing something to be accessible from the beginning. An accommodation often involves modifying an existing environment or experience so that an individual can participate. Universal design, on the other hand, encourages us to anticipate differences among people and design environments that reduce barriers before they become problems.

Both are important. Even thoughtfully designed classrooms will sometimes require individualized accommodations. But consider how we might approach music education differently.

One approach asks, "How can we help this student participate in our existing music program?"

Another asks, "How might we design our music program so that more students have opportunities to participate in the first place?"

The first question focuses on adapting what already exists. The second invites us to imagine something different. And the answers don't have to involve choosing between traditional and popular music education. Band, choir, and orchestra can provide wonderful musical experiences. So can modern band, songwriting, music production, and other approaches. The point isn't that one is better than another, or that every school must offer every possible type of music class.

The point is that students are different, and the musical opportunities we provide should recognize those differences. We already accept this idea in many other areas of education. Students interested in visual art might explore drawing, painting, ceramics, graphic design, or photography. Schools offer different pathways into science, technology, and physical education because students have different interests and goals. Why shouldn't we think the same way about music?

Most importantly, expanding our offerings could let students with and without disabilities participate together in music classes they genuinely want to take. That's not simply accommodation. That's inclusion through design.

Modern Band and the Flexibility of Music-Making

One reason I find modern band particularly interesting through the lens of UDL is its potential flexibility. In a traditional large ensemble, students often have fairly defined roles. A trumpet player plays the trumpet part. A clarinet player plays the clarinet part. The conductor typically makes many musical decisions, and students work together to realize an established interpretation. These experiences can teach valuable musical and collaborative skills.

But modern band can approach participation somewhat differently. A student might play a simple two-chord guitar pattern while another plays a more complex keyboard part. Someone else might contribute a percussion groove, sing, create a loop, or help arrange the song. Students may learn through chord charts, recordings, imitation, experimentation, or notation. Several different ways can contribute meaningfully to the same song.

Most importantly, those roles can change depending on the students.

A student who finds a particular instrument difficult might discover they are quite successful at creating beats or contributing musical ideas through technology. A student who struggles with traditional notation might demonstrate a wonderful ear for music. Another might be an excellent songwriter but have little interest in performing onstage. Modern band provides opportunities to recognize these different kinds of musicianship.

Of course, simply calling something “modern band” doesn't automatically make it accessible. A modern band teacher can create barriers just as easily as any other teacher. The classroom still needs intentional design, and students may still need individualized supports. But I think the flexibility of popular music education creates exciting possibilities for reducing barriers while maintaining meaningful musical learning. We don't have to lower our expectations for what students can accomplish musically. We can expand our understanding of how they might accomplish it.

Universal Design Is Also About Musical Identity

Another aspect of UDL that interests me is its connection to student identity and belonging. Students don't arrive at school without musical experiences (not empty vessels). They bring years of listening, preferences, cultural knowledge, and musical interests. Some students love classical music. Others love rock, country, hip-hop, jazz, pop, or electronic music. Many enjoy several genres and move easily between them. Yet the musical experiences we offer in schools don't always reflect that diversity.

Imagine a student who spends hours at home making beats on a computer. That student may already understand rhythm, texture, form, timbre, and musical expression in sophisticated ways. But if the school music program primarily values traditional instrumental or choral performance, the student may not see those abilities as relevant to school music.

Now imagine that same student entering a music production class where those experiences are recognized and developed. The student isn't suddenly becoming musical. The school is finally giving that student an opportunity for their musicianship to be recognized. I think that's an important distinction.

Universal Design for Learning encourages educators to recognize differences among learners, including their interests, identities, and ways of engaging with learning. Modern band and other forms of popular music education can help us put those ideas into practice. Accessibility isn't only about whether a student can physically or cognitively complete an activity. It's also about whether the learning environment provides meaningful ways for students to participate, contribute, and belong. And sometimes creating that sense of belonging requires expanding what we offer.

But We Can't Just Make These Changes on Monday

I recognize that adding a modern band, songwriting, or music production class isn't something a teacher can simply decide to do on Monday. Developing a new course can involve curriculum committees, administrative approval, scheduling changes, staffing considerations, equipment purchases, professional development, and sometimes school board approval. Depending on the school, the process might take months or even years. Trust me, I understand that reality. But think again about the curb cut.

Turning an existing sidewalk into an accessible curb ramp isn't necessarily quick or easy, either. Someone has to recognize the need, develop a design, secure funding, obtain the appropriate approvals, and complete the construction. Sometimes that process is complicated. Sometimes it takes longer than anyone would like. But we don't use those challenges to argue that accessible sidewalks aren't worth pursuing. We recognize that making our communities more accessible sometimes requires significant changes to the physical structures we've already built.

I think the same is true of music education.

Of course, we should continue making immediate changes within our existing classrooms. We should adapt lessons, offer flexible learning opportunities, and find ways for students with different needs to participate meaningfully. But we shouldn't limit our vision of accessibility to the changes we can make tomorrow. Sometimes the barriers are built into the larger structure of our music programs. Addressing them may require redesigning schedules, developing new courses, rethinking prerequisites, and expanding the types of musical experiences available to students. That work may be difficult, but difficulty doesn't make it any less important.

And there's another beautiful part of the curb-cut analogy. Once a curb cut is constructed, people benefit from it for years. Someone using a wheelchair doesn't have to request a special accommodation every time they reach that intersection. Accessibility is built into the environment. Similarly, once a school establishes a well-designed modern band, songwriting, or music production course, that opportunity can serve students year after year. Students don't have to repeatedly advocate for an entirely new musical pathway. The opportunity is already there.

Sometimes the most meaningful changes we make in music education aren't the ones that help a single student participate tomorrow. They're the ones that make participation possible for students we haven't even met yet.

Recognizing Where the Curbs Are

I don't think every music educator needs to become a modern band teacher, and I certainly don't believe every school should abandon its traditional ensembles. But I do think we have a responsibility to consider whether the structures we've created are serving our students as fully as they could. Maybe the curb is a prerequisite that requires years of instrumental experience before students can participate.

Maybe it's a music curriculum that offers few opportunities for students interested in creating their own music.

Maybe it's a rehearsal structure that makes participation difficult for some students with disabilities.

Maybe it's an expectation that students must read traditional notation before we recognize them as musicians.

Or maybe our music programs have been designed around the interests and experiences of the students who already participate, without giving enough consideration to those who don't.

We can't remove every barrier immediately. Some require resources, collaboration, policy changes, and considerable planning. But before we can address a barrier, we have to recognize that it exists. And I think that's where music educators can begin.

We can look beyond our classrooms and ask who isn't participating. We can listen to students whose musical interests aren't represented in our curriculum. We can explore new approaches to music-making. We can begin conversations with administrators and colleagues about expanding opportunities, even when those changes may take years to accomplish. We can also recognize that removing barriers for one group of students may create wonderful opportunities for many others.

That's what I find so compelling about modern band and other forms of popular music education as examples of universal design. A course that provides an accessible pathway for a student with a disability might also welcome the student who loves hip-hop, the student who plays guitar at home, the student who wants to write songs, and the student who never imagined school music could be something they would enjoy.

One change. Many beneficiaries.

Just like a curb cut.

The goal isn't simply to help more students fit into the music programs we've already created. It's to imagine music programs designed with enough flexibility, variety, and opportunity that more students can find a place in them. And while that may require changes that are neither quick nor easy, I think it's a vision worth pursuing.

We don't expect every music teacher to build a curb cut tomorrow. But we should expect ourselves to recognize where the curbs are.

Previous
Previous

MUSIBUS: The Bus That Could Go Anywhere, But Didn't

Next
Next

The Musician We Might Have Missed